Asphalt Shingles vs Modified Shingles vs Cedar Shakes: Insights from a Roof Replacement Company in Highland Park, Illinois

Roof replacement company in Highland Park Illinois

Asphalt Shingles vs Modified Shingles vs Cedar Shakes: Insights from a Roof Replacement Company in Highland Park, Illinois

When it comes to residential roofing, some of the most popular materials include asphalt shingles, modified shingles, and cedar shakes. Each option has its own merits, and its own drawbacks as well.

To help you find the right option for your home, this roof replacement company in Highland Park, Illinois is going to compare each of these materials below.


In terms of sheer durability, cedar shakes reign supreme. They tend to last 40 to 50 years, as they’re not only resistant to cracking, but to warping as well. That said, for them to make it this far, they require quite a bit of maintenance.

Modified shingles are next in durability. They tend to last around 35 years. They require almost nothing in terms of maintenance.

Asphalt shingles are the least durable of the three. They generally last around 30 years when properly installed by a roof replacement company in Highland Park, Illinois. Again, they don’t require much in terms of maintenance.

Maintenance Requirements

We’ve alluded to the materials’ maintenance needs. Now, let’s discuss their specifics. Cedar shakes require not just regular cleaning, but regular sealing and staining as well. If you fail to seal them, they’ll become ultra-susceptible to water and sun damage, and they will deteriorate prematurely.

Modified shingles generally only need to be cleaned on occasion. If you keep them free of algae, you shouldn’t have to worry about them deteriorating prematurely. Asphalt shingles are essentially identical to modified shingles in this regard. However, because their construction isn’t as high quality, they tend to deteriorate faster.


Up next is cost. Cedar shakes are generally the most expensive option of the three. Not only are they more expensive to purchase, but more expensive to install as well. Plus, because they require intensive maintenance, they cost more over time.

Modified shingles are up on the list. Their purchase price is around 66% of what the purchase price of cedar shakes is. Note, though, that they are more affordable to install and don’t require intensive and expensive maintenance.

Asphalt shingles are around half the price of cedar shakes. They’re also more affordable to install. Like modified shingles, they require almost no maintenance, which makes them an affordable option in that regard.


Aesthetically speaking, it all comes down to personal preference. However, there are visual differences in these materials.

Cedar shakes possess a textured and layered aesthetic. They’re rustic in appearance, and they will instantly stand out among other roofing materials in the neighborhood.

Modified and asphalt shingles look essentially the same. They sit flat on their respective roofs and are available in both rectangular and square shapes. They’re also available in a wide variety of colors.

If you want a conventional look, asphalt and modified shingles will suit you well. If you want eccentric or eclectic, your roof replacement company in Highland Park, Illinois may recommend going with cedar shakes.


In terms of insulation, cedar shakes are very good. They do a great job of keeping out heat and cold, and therefore, they are highly energy efficient.

Asphalt shingles and modified shingles don’t lack insulation. However, they’re not on cedar shakes’ level in this regard. Therefore, they won’t save you as much money on energy costs over time.

Looking for a Roof Replacement Company in Highland Park, Illinois?

Are you ready to have a new roof installed? Looking for the top-rated roof replacement company in Highland Park, Illinois? If so, look no further than the team at Aspen Exterior Company.

We have installed a wide variety of roofs for homeowners throughout the Highland Park area for decades. Regardless of your roofing needs, we can get the job done right. Contact us today at (847) 590-5600 to request a free estimate.

No Comments

Post A Comment

Call Now Button(847) 590-5600